Khadar monastery. The monument group of churches
The Khadar monastery occupies a limited area, which means the buildings included in it are placed close to each other. However, due to the complex relief and significant slope of the site, they are built on platforms of different heights. The Surb Astvatsatsin Church is located on the top of the cape, along with the bell tower, the gate, the cells, and one structure of larger residential dimensions. Another structure of secular significance is placed on the lowest platform, which presumably was the monastery's library (Hasratyan, 1992, 68; Fig. 1).
The religious structures of the monastery are represented by a complex of monuments, comprising a central church and its associated chapels. This architectural ensemble showcases a distinctive and original design that sets it apart from other medieval Armenian churches. The central church consists of three interconnected churches, forming a cohesive unit. At the heart of this composition is a four-pillar domed structure, which is cross-shaped on the interior and rectangular on the exterior. This central structure links two chapel churches via a rectangular tabernacle positioned on the north and south sides. These chapel churches, with vaulted halls, are dedicated to different saints: the northern one to Saint Prokopius and the southern one to Saint Minas (Jalaleants 1842, 205). They feature simple architectural designs and modest dimensions, measuring 2.2 x 3.5 meters and 2.4 x 2.5 meters, respectively. Both chapels extend from east to west and are capped by a rectangular tabernacle on their eastern ends. The chapels, having the same width as the prayer halls of the churches, are delineated by wall pillars and an arch spanning between them. This architectural concept is frequently observed in Artsakh, evident in the churches of Dadivank, Gtchavank, Yeghisha Arakyal, "Bri Yeghtsi," "Okhte Yeghtsi," Charektar, Handaberd, and numerous other monasteries (Petrosyan et al. 2009, 34). Architectural analysis of this group of monuments reveals that these smaller chapels predate the construction of the domed church. As the domed church was built, the existing chapels were integrated into its design and spatial arrangement. This approach resulted in a highly original and atypical asymmetric solution in the context of classical Armenian church architecture.
The church features a four-column dome structure, with the columns shifted to the west. As a result, the dome is positioned towards the western side of the hall, rather than centrally as is typical. The side chapels are integrated into the main church structure, with the entrance to the northern chapel located on its southern wall and the entrance to the southern chapel on its western side. Both entrances lead into the prayer hall of the later-constructed church. The eastern end of the church culminates in a semi-circular tabernacle (fig. 2) and includes a single sacristy situated on the northern side. A niche in the southern wall provides access to a hiding place above. Additionally, there are four arched niches within the tabernacle, each adorned with stalactite sculptures at their edges (Fig. 3).
The southeastern part of the church is completely occupied by the chapel on the south side. The chapel on the northeast side is slightly shifted to the north, creating a narrow corridor space. The entrances to both the chapel and the sacristy open into this corridor. This section is covered with a quarter-cylindrical vault, while the southern and northern parts are covered with semi-circular vaults (Fig. 4). The dome covering the central part of the church is unique in its design, inspired by the forms used in vestibules and gavits. The transition from the square base beneath the dome to the dome itself is achieved using pendentives (Fig. 5). These pendentives transform the square base into an octagon, upon which the octagonal dome with a wide opening at the top rests. Garret is the only source of light in the prayer hall because the dome lacks a drum, and the windows in the outer walls are few and narrow.
Solutions for a dome without a drum are found in the architecture of gavits. These principles of spatial resolution for four-columned gavits first emerged in the gavit of the Sanahin Monastery. In the gavit of the Sanahin, Goshavank, and Kecharis monasteries, the quadrilateral form of the roof appears, and the drum almost disappears (Mnatsakanyan 1952, 43-53). The dome of the Khadar Monastery church also follows this design, which is not coincidental. The columns supporting the dome on the eastern side of the main church of Khatravank are rectangular in cross-section. The southern column is a masonry structure attached to the church's south wall from the inside. These columns lack anchors and rest on high pedestals, ending with slab, heel-shaped middle, and half-cylindrical capitals. Of the four pillars, two are made from a single piece of stone, while the other two are constructed from two pieces (Fig. 6). The sculptures on the pedestals are particularly remarkable. The north side of the southwest pillar pedestal features a stylized lion's head, the west side of the northeast pillar displays a ram, and the side of the wall facing the dome space includes ox heads. Additionally, the west side of the wall's plinth shows a pair of coiled snakes. These animal-shaped sculptures are common in Armenian architecture and serve as protective symbols (Mnatsakanyan 1970, 188). The western entrance of the church also boasts artistic decoration. The rectangular door opening is set within a niche crowned by an arch resting on semi-columns.
Many khachkars were used as building stones in various facades of the churches, serving both as decorative elements and adding a sense of liveliness to the otherwise simple construction of the buildings (Fig. 7). This construction technique, which combines semi-polished and rough stones with khachkars, is typical of both the Artsakh and Syunik schools of architecture and is evidenced in many monuments (Petrosyan et al. 2009, 42).
The volumetric and spatial solutions of the Khadar Monastery are quite original. The church itself has an almost cube-shaped volume with a pyramidal roof, where the pediments are not distinct, and the walls all end at the same height. The side chapels do not have separate roofs but are instead covered by the continuation of the church roof's slopes. The roof was constructed with semi-cylindrical tiles, as evidenced by both the tiles on the roof and their spills (Fig. 8).
The churches of the Khadar Monastery, along with other buildings, are constructed from rough basalt stones bound with lime mortar. The burial arches, columns, and pillars are lined with hewn stones. Inside, the walls are plastered with lime mortar.
Bibliography
- Hasratyan 1992 - Hasratyan M., Artsakh School of Armenian Architecture, Publishing House of the Academy of Sciences of RA, Yerevan.
- Mnatsakanyan 1970 - Mnatsakanyan S., Protective emblems in medieval Armenian sculpture, Historical and Philosophical Journal, No. 3, pp. 185-202.
- Petrosyan et al. 2009 - Petrosyan H., Kirakosyan L., Safaryan V., Handaberd Monastery and its excavations, "Science"(Gitutyun) publishing house of the Academy of Sciences of RA, Yerevan., Yerevan.
- Jalalyants 1842 - Jalalyants S., Journey to Greater Armenia, Part 1, Tiflis.
- Mnatsakanyan 1952 - Mnatsakanyan S., Architecture of Armenian Narthexes, Yerevan.
Khadar monastery. The monument group of churches
Artsakh